Colonial Diner in Middletown

8 Dolson Ave, Middletown, NY 10940-6425, Middletown

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Diner
  • Vegetarian Friendly
Features
  • Takeout
  • Seating
  • Waitstaff
  • Wheelchair Accessible
Good for
  • Kids
  • Families witd children

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Colonial Diner
BH
Benedict Hudson
google
05.26.2024
5/5

Awesome diner, owner was super nice and Terri our waitress was super nice too. Need more bright spots like that in Middletown

Colonial Diner
JW
Jacqueline Watson
google
11.24.2018
5/5

Perfect diner and comfort food. Accommodations were easily accepted for changes to meal. Service was outstanding. Diner was clean. Prices were appropriate. Portions were large. All extras were given plentiful. Everyone was pleasant. Bathroom is very small but clean. Excellent for family dining.

Colonial Diner
Nman321
google
09.26.2018
1/5

I’ve been here a few times. I don’t think the food is that great. I’ve gotten the chicken deluxe and the panini with chicken tenders. The chicken deluxe had hardly any flavor. Also the chicken tenders are not very crispy and were pretty bland.. It was also strange that the panini was in a roll, instead of flat bread like a panini usually is. Also they have a huge amount of health violations. I think they had the most violations in Orange County. Don’t know how they’re still open honestly. Would avoid if you’re careful about that kinda stuff.

Colonial Diner
Dre
google
08.21.2018
4/5

Staff is friendly & The food is served quickly. The place is designed nice

Colonial Diner
SG
Stephanie Gamboni
google
08.13.2018
5/5

Great food - Great service - we were delighted & enjoyed our lunch.wud recommend to anyone who will listen. Our waitress very patient & gracious.

Colonial Diner
EG
Elizabeth Guamani
google
08.01.2018
5/5

This was not my first visit to this diner and it definitely wasn't the last either. The food here is always amazing and the prices are just right. The staff is very friendly and the service was quick. The time it took them to prepare the food for my party of 3 was even super quick.

Colonial Diner
nI
norii I
google
07.19.2018
1/5

The food was not as expected to be. Bad service. Although the ladies were really nice the food was the problem. :)

Colonial Diner
SM
Sierra Medynski
google
06.26.2018
5/5

This place was great, got our food hot and ready within 15 mins. They're doing take out and it was delicious 👍

Colonial Diner
FK
Fred Kalena
google
06.11.2018
5/5

Gem of a local diner! Great food quality and selection. Prices are reasonable and are in-line with other diners I have visited. Staff is very friendly and attentive. Awesome selection of desserts that will make your mouth water! Easy access with ample parking. Located just minutes off of I84 exit 3 and Dolson Avenue in Middletown. RECOMMENDED! 😎

Colonial Diner
LV
Laura Vitaliani
google
06.01.2018
2/5

Food was sub par. French onion soup is not yellow. And use a slice of toasted baguette in it instead of the stale tiny croutons before topping it with the cheese.

Colonial Diner
PL
Paul Laibach
google
05.22.2018
5/5

Excellent food, friendly service, and reasonable prices.

Colonial Diner
hg
henry gitner
google
05.07.2018
5/5

Great friendly service, excellent breakfast, spotlessly clean, all employees wearing masks.

Colonial Diner
VR
Van RG
google
03.09.2018
4/5

I love diners. This is a pretty standard American diner. They've got huge servings, I'm always taking leftovers home. My favorite is the matzo ball soup, but I get that everywhere that serves it. Dinner specials are pretty good. Dessert servings are huge. They always have fresh and yummy cakes. Bathrooms are decent. Waitstaff are dolls. Very sweet. During late hours, menu is limited.Good coffee. Try the ribs. Tasty. Avoid the gyro, and moussaka. I wasn't crazy about it.

Colonial Diner
DS
Dee Stebbins
google
01.27.2018
5/5

The food is absolutely amazing!! We had the prime rib special...it was an inch thick, served just as we asked with potatoe, soup or salad and jello or pudding...there was so much food we took home enough for another meal...very highly recommend the Colonial Diner!!

Colonial Diner
DH
David Huffman
google
01.21.2018
5/5

My wife and I are from Texas. We found this wonderful place to eat. Great tasting food, good size portions and a friendly staff. A must have experience for travelers.

Colonial Diner
JR
Jason Reed
google
01.11.2018
5/5

One of our favorite diners to go to on date night.

Colonial Diner
SJ
Sarah J
google
01.11.2018
4/5

Had the eggplant Parm and it was really good. Their specials are ten dollars and include a salad or soup, and a dessert. Great deal for that price. Only issue I had is that they had no wifi.

Colonial Diner
ML
Maria Little
google
11.09.2017
5/5

Our waitress Carmen was AMAZING! she was the ONLY waitress on for the night of the Tim McGraw concert! There were at least 15 or more tables & she did an excellent job!! Continuously pleasant & was quick with service to everyone! Could not believe how she did it all by herself so efficiently w/friendliness & professionalism. And kudos to the chef for keeping up with the orders.

Colonial Diner
IX
I.E. Xam
google
10.21.2017
3/5

Typical diner. Huge menu. Food is good value. Great service.

Colonial Diner
OB
Owen Barnes
google
09.25.2017
5/5

Food was great, service was great, menu had a lot of great options. Was inexpensive and the portion sizes were plenty. Couldn't quite finish it all even having skipped breakfast. Was recommended by a local and did not disappoint. Went out of my way to try it and I'd do it again. Also, the view from my booth was amazing!

Colonial Diner
SS
Sammi Smith
google
09.05.2017
4/5

The food here is pretty great, their service is pretty speedy, and the prices are decent. Would definitely recommend if you're looking for a place to eat with friends and/or family. As for the service, the waiters and waitresses that I have had are all personable, friendly, and really great at doing their jobs and then some.

Colonial Diner
DayDrian
google
09.02.2017
4/5

Been coming here for years not a bad place just not fond of there sweet potatoe fries anymore they make them different I rather the old ways

Colonial Diner
jl
joshua lee
google
08.14.2017
5/5

Great service, great food! And im always satisfied with the prices i couldnt ask for a better spot to eat at

Colonial Diner
VA
Vladimir Alvarez
google
08.13.2017
5/5

One of my favorite. Carmen is great and Vicky the owner very vood people.

Colonial Diner
YA
Yasmine Ashton
google
07.26.2017
4/5

I got breakfast and the food was delicious. Great menu. Nice, cozy atmosphere. I went here on a date and I was not disappointed.

Colonial Diner
kb
kelli barclay
google
05.17.2017
5/5

Wonderful place I been going there for 42yrs. The best I love the waitresses there so kind.

Colonial Diner
jc
jay corriveau
google
05.14.2017
5/5

Lovely staff. Solid diner food. Clean comfortable place.

Colonial Diner
CC
Craig Cohen
google
05.08.2017
5/5

Always a good meal here and ask for Carmen as your server she's the best

Colonial Diner
MG
Michael Grant
google
01.23.2017
5/5

Great classic diner. Great food and service. I love diners and this one rates high on my list. Also wanted to mention that the restaurant was clean and looked like recent remodeling - like new. This includes the table chairs, and booths. Kids were happy with their kids meal which included jello or ice cream. I dont live in the area but I'll remember to stop there if I'm in the area.

Colonial Diner
JC
Jam Cam
google
01.22.2017
5/5

Great family run resturant with a large variety of meals. Big portions too.

Colonial Diner
NI
Norma Irizarry
google
01.17.2017
5/5

I always enjoy eating here. They have gluten free bread and wraps. Their milkshakes are good and the staff is always friendly. It is usually quite and is a relaxing place to eat.

Colonial Diner
PM
Pete Matthews
google
11.09.2016
5/5

Good food. Great people

Colonial Diner
CM
Carmen Mack
google
10.10.2016
5/5

Oh my gosh. We love this place. Fast friendly service. Great food. Large portions. Spacious and clean. Good prices. This is a hidden treasure for travelers. We will come back each time we come to Middletown.

Colonial Diner
MS
Marco Soriano
google
10.07.2016
5/5

One of the best places I have bein to. service and food was of the best.

Colonial Diner
JE
Joe Estrella
google
09.26.2016
5/5

Very good food and terrific staff🤗👍

Colonial Diner
RR
Robert Rosen
google
09.25.2016
5/5

Last visit wasn't good. Food order was wrong, took along time to get, wait staff wasn't very pleasant. Previous visits were always great.

Colonial Diner
LG
Lauritz Gröger
google
09.12.2016
4/5

Good solid food for a cheap price

Colonial Diner
gc
george crinnion
google
08.27.2016
5/5

Typical good diner style food. Nothing fancy which is just fine by me.

Colonial Diner
NH
Nailah Harris
google
08.25.2016
2/5

My experience was not the greatest. My burger had to be done over. I asked for a medium well and I received an extremely well/burnt burger. I asked for another and it was a better burger still well done though. Anyway, the fried scallops were chewy and no good. Otherwise, everyone else seemed to be okay with their food. I love diners, however, I will visit a different one the next time I visit.

Colonial Diner
DF
Debra Fiore
google
07.06.2016
1/5

Maybe it's just because I am a city gal, but when you order a cheese omelette with bacon and the bacon is hard as a rock, and the cheese is not actually cheddar but a shredded mix that is not melted it gives you pause. Not to mention you ask for water with lemon and you are handed lemons that are visible rotten I went to the nearest Starbucks for some yogurt.

Colonial Diner
sn
stevvve nikosss
google
05.19.2016
5/5

Fast service, friendly staff and cozy diner!!Large menu,reasonable prices!!

Colonial Diner
DH
Debbie Hete
google
03.23.2016
5/5

Great friendly service and food.

Colonial Diner
AM
Amanda Martinez
google
03.01.2016
4/5

Feels like home. Nice people. Good service.

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 18453423500

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!